When a radial piston motor stops holding a load on a slope, most maintenance teams replace it. In our experience perhaps one third of those motors needed only a distributor plate and a set of piston bushings. The difference between the two decisions is one measurement: case drain flow at rated pressure — ninety minutes and a flow meter, converting a guess into a number.
This is the protocol we use when customers return motors for evaluation, and the one we recommend on site for Poclain MS/MK, Rexroth MCR and JMDG series motors.
A radial piston motor has three leakage paths, failing on different timescales:
Only the first two appear in case drain flow — which is why a motor can leak visibly at the shaft and still be internally healthy, and a dry motor can be internally finished.
Theoretical flow is speed multiplied by displacement. Volumetric efficiency is then:
ηv = Qt / (Qt + Qleak) × 100%, where Qt = n × Vd / 1000 (L/min), n in r/min and Vd in ml/r.
Worked example, MS125 group at 15,000 ml/r turning 30 r/min: Qt = 450 L/min. A measured case drain of 22 L/min gives ηv = 450 / 472 = 95.3%, which is healthy. A case drain of 90 L/min gives 83.3%, which is a motor on its way out.
| Case drain as % of theoretical flow | Volumetric efficiency | Assessment | Recommendation |
|---|---|---|---|
| ≤ 5% | ≥ 95% | New or freshly rebuilt condition | Record as baseline |
| 5–10% | 90–95% | Normal service wear | Re-test at next 2,000 h interval |
| 10–15% | 85–90% | Advanced wear, torque loss noticeable in duty cycle | Plan rebuild; check oil cleanliness first |
| > 15% | < 85% | End of life for critical duty | Rebuild or replace; investigate contamination source |
Two adjustments to these bands: high-hour motors on low-duty applications (winches, positioning drives) often run acceptably at 88%; and any motor driving a machine with a brake-holding requirement should be pulled at 10%, because leakage converts directly into drift.
A contractor reported an MCR5 wheel motor on a skid steer that would not hold position on a ramp. Bench test showed 18.4% case drain leakage at 25 MPa with oil at 48 °C. Teardown found a scored distributor face and three worn piston bushings with no damage to the crankshaft or housing. Replacement of the distributor plate, bushings and seals restored leakage to 4.1%, at roughly a third of the cost of a new unit. Root cause was a return filter bypass left open after a previous service — the ISO cleanliness code at the reservoir was 21/19/16.
That last number is the point: leakage measurement tells you how worn the motor is, oil analysis tells you why.
Case drain flow does not separate distributor wear from bushing wear, does not detect a cracked piston, and will read falsely low if the case drain line itself is restricted. It also says nothing about mechanical efficiency — a motor can pass the leakage test and still be noisy because of bearing damage. Where torque loss is accompanied by knock or vibration, the unit needs teardown regardless of the leakage figure.
Prepared by the technical service team at Ningbo Helm Tower Noda Hydraulic Co., Ltd. (established 2004, ISO 9001 certified). The acceptance bands above are our field practice for MS/MK, MCR and JMDG series motors, not a substitute for the OEM specification of a specific model code. Spare piston bushings, distributor plates and seal kits are available for the series we manufacture and remanufacture.
When a radial piston motor stops holding a load on a slope, most maintenance teams replace it. In our experience perhaps one third of those motors needed only a distributor plate and a set of piston bushings. The difference between the two decisions is one measurement: case drain flow at rated pressure — ninety minutes and a flow meter, converting a guess into a number.
This is the protocol we use when customers return motors for evaluation, and the one we recommend on site for Poclain MS/MK, Rexroth MCR and JMDG series motors.
A radial piston motor has three leakage paths, failing on different timescales:
Only the first two appear in case drain flow — which is why a motor can leak visibly at the shaft and still be internally healthy, and a dry motor can be internally finished.
Theoretical flow is speed multiplied by displacement. Volumetric efficiency is then:
ηv = Qt / (Qt + Qleak) × 100%, where Qt = n × Vd / 1000 (L/min), n in r/min and Vd in ml/r.
Worked example, MS125 group at 15,000 ml/r turning 30 r/min: Qt = 450 L/min. A measured case drain of 22 L/min gives ηv = 450 / 472 = 95.3%, which is healthy. A case drain of 90 L/min gives 83.3%, which is a motor on its way out.
| Case drain as % of theoretical flow | Volumetric efficiency | Assessment | Recommendation |
|---|---|---|---|
| ≤ 5% | ≥ 95% | New or freshly rebuilt condition | Record as baseline |
| 5–10% | 90–95% | Normal service wear | Re-test at next 2,000 h interval |
| 10–15% | 85–90% | Advanced wear, torque loss noticeable in duty cycle | Plan rebuild; check oil cleanliness first |
| > 15% | < 85% | End of life for critical duty | Rebuild or replace; investigate contamination source |
Two adjustments to these bands: high-hour motors on low-duty applications (winches, positioning drives) often run acceptably at 88%; and any motor driving a machine with a brake-holding requirement should be pulled at 10%, because leakage converts directly into drift.
A contractor reported an MCR5 wheel motor on a skid steer that would not hold position on a ramp. Bench test showed 18.4% case drain leakage at 25 MPa with oil at 48 °C. Teardown found a scored distributor face and three worn piston bushings with no damage to the crankshaft or housing. Replacement of the distributor plate, bushings and seals restored leakage to 4.1%, at roughly a third of the cost of a new unit. Root cause was a return filter bypass left open after a previous service — the ISO cleanliness code at the reservoir was 21/19/16.
That last number is the point: leakage measurement tells you how worn the motor is, oil analysis tells you why.
Case drain flow does not separate distributor wear from bushing wear, does not detect a cracked piston, and will read falsely low if the case drain line itself is restricted. It also says nothing about mechanical efficiency — a motor can pass the leakage test and still be noisy because of bearing damage. Where torque loss is accompanied by knock or vibration, the unit needs teardown regardless of the leakage figure.
Prepared by the technical service team at Ningbo Helm Tower Noda Hydraulic Co., Ltd. (established 2004, ISO 9001 certified). The acceptance bands above are our field practice for MS/MK, MCR and JMDG series motors, not a substitute for the OEM specification of a specific model code. Spare piston bushings, distributor plates and seal kits are available for the series we manufacture and remanufacture.